← All posts
21 November 2026 · Housing & Building · 4 min read

New home sales have fallen hard, and that was before the last rate rise

New home sales fell 19.3% in October, before the Cup Day rate rise even landed. Why this new home sales slump means the RBA should hold in December.

New home sales fell 19.3% in October. Not my number. It’s from the Housing Industry Association’s monthly survey of the biggest volume builders, released on Tuesday. Every one of the five states surveyed went backwards in October.

Take a slightly longer view and it looks worse. Sales over the three months to October were 17.4% lower than the three months before, and 27.3% lower than the same time last year.

And the bit that worries me most is the timing. HIA says this new home sales slump came before the Reserve Bank’s Cup Day rise to 4.85%. So that last increase isn’t in these numbers yet. HIA reckons it can take up to six months for a rate rise to fully show up in new home sales.

Queensland is copping it

Over the three months to October, Queensland had the biggest fall of any state, down 36.8%. New South Wales was down 24.5%, Victoria 16.1% and South Australia 4.3%. Western Australia was the one state that held its ground over those three months, up 0.3%, even though it went backwards along with everyone else in October itself.

That fits with what we’re seeing up here. Brisbane prices fell further than any other capital in October, Brisbane auctions have been clearing at around one in four, and Queensland had the biggest fall in owner-occupier lending in the September quarter. Now the contracts that keep builders busy next year are drying up too.

The new home sales slump hasn’t hit builders yet

Right now most builders still look busy. That’s because sales were stronger earlier this year and those jobs are still being built. HIA expects the slump in sales to start showing up in building approvals in the March quarter of 2027, and detached home starts to fall from around the middle of next year unless things improve early in the new year.

That’s how this industry works. The pain shows up in sales first, then approvals, then starts, then jobs. By the time the government sees fewer homes being built, the damage was done a year earlier.

The issue is that builders still think they’re busy and underestimate the slowdown coming. By the time many of them realise, it’s too late. Then they have to take drastic action, or worse, they can’t finish their current jobs. Then the ripple goes right through the trades.

The tax carve-out isn’t enough on its own

I’ve said before that the new tax rules favour new homes. From 1 July 2027, investors who buy a new home after Budget night keep negative gearing and can still choose the 50% capital gains discount. I still think that’s right, and buyers should know it.

But HIA makes a fair point this week. Keeping the tax breaks for new homes doesn’t mean more people will build them. I’d go further. If rates keep going up and established prices keep falling, plenty of buyers will simply wait. A tax break doesn’t help much if you can’t get the loan in the first place.

The Reserve Bank was split, and I’m with the three

The minutes of the November meeting came out on Tuesday. Six members voted to raise rates and three wanted to hold. The three who wanted to hold were worried the economy might be close to a much sharper downturn, and pointed to the cost in jobs.

Two days later the ABS reported unemployment had risen to 4.9% in October, the highest since late 2021. Those three saw what most Australians already know: the rises are hurting ordinary Australians.

I understand the Bank is worried about inflation, and some of the price pressure is real. But a lot of it is coming from fuel, and in my view government spending isn’t helping. New home sales are telling us households have already pulled right back.

What should happen now

  • For the Reserve Bank: hold in December and let the five rises this year do their work. The new home sales figures are a leading indicator. Don’t wait for the approvals and jobs data to confirm what we can already see.
  • For governments: if you want the homes in the Housing Accord, now is the time to cut the costs you control. Infrastructure charges, stamp duty on new homes and slow approvals all add to the price of a new home at the exact moment buyers are walking away.
  • For buyers: builders with gaps in their schedules for the second half of 2027 will want your job. Do your homework on the builder, get the contract checked, and make sure you’re comfortable with the repayments if rates stay where they are.

The tax comments are general information, not tax or financial advice. Talk to your accountant about your own situation.

Darren Wallis is Chairman of G.J. Gardner Homes and was its CEO and Managing Director from 2000 to 2020.

Data: HIA, ABS, RBA, Cotality

Want Darren to talk about this at your event?

Book Darren More posts